Innovative Protocol That Processes Saliva Samples with Bead Mill Homogenizer Before RT-PCR Testing Improves COVID-19 Detection Rate
|
By LabMedica International staff writers Posted on 14 Jun 2021 |

Image: Schematic overview of sample processing and severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) assay workflow, depicting main steps (Photo courtesy of Nikhil S. Sahajpal)
The addition of a simple processing step to saliva samples before testing may improve COVID-19 detection rate, eliminate the challenges of nasopharyngeal testing, and facilitate mass surveillance, according to researchers.
A team of researchers from Augusta University (Augusta, GA, USA) has found that an innovative protocol that processes saliva samples with a bead mill homogenizer before real-time PCR (RT-PCR) testing results in higher sensitivity compared to NPS samples. The collection of nasopharyngeal swab (NPS) samples for COVID-19 diagnostic testing poses challenges including exposure risk to healthcare workers and supply chain constraints. Saliva samples are easier to collect but can be mixed with mucus or blood, and some studies have found they produce less accurate results.
The study included samples from a hospital and nursing home as well as from a drive-through testing site. In the first phase (protocol U), 240 matched NPS and saliva sample pairs were tested prospectively for SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR. In the second phase of the study (SalivaAll), 189 matched pairs, including 85 that had been previously evaluated with protocol U, were processed in an Omni bead mill homogenizer before RT-PCR testing. An additional study was conducted with samples with both protocol U and SalivaAll to determine if bead homogenization would affect the clinical sensitivity in NPS samples. Finally, a five-sample pooling strategy was evaluated. Twenty positive pools containing one positive and four negative samples were processed with the Omni bead homogenizer before pooling for SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR testing and compared to controls.
In Phase I, 28.3% of samples tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 from either NPS, saliva, or both. The detection rate was lower in saliva compared to NPS (50.0% vs. 89.7%). In Phase II, 50.2% of samples tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 from either saliva, NPS, or both. The detection rate was higher in saliva compared to NPS samples (97.8% vs. 78.9%). Of the 85 saliva samples tested with both protocols, the detection rate was 100% for samples tested with SalivaAll and 36.7% with protocol U.
According to the researchers, the underlying issues associated with lower sensitivity of saliva to RT-PCR testing could be attributed to the gel-like consistency of saliva samples, which made it difficult to accurately pipet samples into extraction plates for nucleic acid extraction. Adding the homogenization step rendered the saliva samples to uniform viscosity and consistency, making it easier to pipet for the downstream assay. The researchers also successfully validated saliva samples in the five-sample pooling strategy. The pooled testing results demonstrated a positive agreement of 95%, and the negative agreement was found to be 100%. Pooled testing will be critical for SARS-CoV-2 mass surveillance as schools reopen, travel and tourism resume, and people return to offices.
“Saliva as a sample type for COVID-19 testing was a game changer in our fight against the pandemic. It helped us with increased compliance from the population for testing along with decreased exposure risk to the healthcare workers during the collection process,” said lead investigator Ravindra Kolhe, MD, PhD, Department of Pathology, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta University. “Monitoring SARS-CoV-2 will remain a public health need. The use of a non-invasive collection method and easily accessible sample such as saliva will enhance screening and surveillance activities and bypass the need for sterile swabs, expensive transport media, and exposure risk, and even the need for skilled healthcare workers for sample collection.”
Related Links:
Augusta University
A team of researchers from Augusta University (Augusta, GA, USA) has found that an innovative protocol that processes saliva samples with a bead mill homogenizer before real-time PCR (RT-PCR) testing results in higher sensitivity compared to NPS samples. The collection of nasopharyngeal swab (NPS) samples for COVID-19 diagnostic testing poses challenges including exposure risk to healthcare workers and supply chain constraints. Saliva samples are easier to collect but can be mixed with mucus or blood, and some studies have found they produce less accurate results.
The study included samples from a hospital and nursing home as well as from a drive-through testing site. In the first phase (protocol U), 240 matched NPS and saliva sample pairs were tested prospectively for SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR. In the second phase of the study (SalivaAll), 189 matched pairs, including 85 that had been previously evaluated with protocol U, were processed in an Omni bead mill homogenizer before RT-PCR testing. An additional study was conducted with samples with both protocol U and SalivaAll to determine if bead homogenization would affect the clinical sensitivity in NPS samples. Finally, a five-sample pooling strategy was evaluated. Twenty positive pools containing one positive and four negative samples were processed with the Omni bead homogenizer before pooling for SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR testing and compared to controls.
In Phase I, 28.3% of samples tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 from either NPS, saliva, or both. The detection rate was lower in saliva compared to NPS (50.0% vs. 89.7%). In Phase II, 50.2% of samples tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 from either saliva, NPS, or both. The detection rate was higher in saliva compared to NPS samples (97.8% vs. 78.9%). Of the 85 saliva samples tested with both protocols, the detection rate was 100% for samples tested with SalivaAll and 36.7% with protocol U.
According to the researchers, the underlying issues associated with lower sensitivity of saliva to RT-PCR testing could be attributed to the gel-like consistency of saliva samples, which made it difficult to accurately pipet samples into extraction plates for nucleic acid extraction. Adding the homogenization step rendered the saliva samples to uniform viscosity and consistency, making it easier to pipet for the downstream assay. The researchers also successfully validated saliva samples in the five-sample pooling strategy. The pooled testing results demonstrated a positive agreement of 95%, and the negative agreement was found to be 100%. Pooled testing will be critical for SARS-CoV-2 mass surveillance as schools reopen, travel and tourism resume, and people return to offices.
“Saliva as a sample type for COVID-19 testing was a game changer in our fight against the pandemic. It helped us with increased compliance from the population for testing along with decreased exposure risk to the healthcare workers during the collection process,” said lead investigator Ravindra Kolhe, MD, PhD, Department of Pathology, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta University. “Monitoring SARS-CoV-2 will remain a public health need. The use of a non-invasive collection method and easily accessible sample such as saliva will enhance screening and surveillance activities and bypass the need for sterile swabs, expensive transport media, and exposure risk, and even the need for skilled healthcare workers for sample collection.”
Related Links:
Augusta University
Latest COVID-19 News
- New Immunosensor Paves Way to Rapid POC Testing for COVID-19 and Emerging Infectious Diseases
- Long COVID Etiologies Found in Acute Infection Blood Samples
- Novel Device Detects COVID-19 Antibodies in Five Minutes
- CRISPR-Powered COVID-19 Test Detects SARS-CoV-2 in 30 Minutes Using Gene Scissors
- Gut Microbiome Dysbiosis Linked to COVID-19
- Novel SARS CoV-2 Rapid Antigen Test Validated for Diagnostic Accuracy
- New COVID + Flu + R.S.V. Test to Help Prepare for `Tripledemic`
- AI Takes Guesswork Out Of Lateral Flow Testing
- Fastest Ever SARS-CoV-2 Antigen Test Designed for Non-Invasive COVID-19 Testing in Any Setting
- Rapid Antigen Tests Detect Omicron, Delta SARS-CoV-2 Variants
- Health Care Professionals Showed Increased Interest in POC Technologies During Pandemic, Finds Study
- Set Up Reserve Lab Capacity Now for Faster Response to Next Pandemic, Say Researchers
- Blood Test Performed During Initial Infection Predicts Long COVID Risk
- Low-Cost COVID-19 Testing Platform Combines Sensitivity of PCR and Speed of Antigen Tests
- Finger-Prick Blood Test Identifies Immunity to COVID-19
- Quick Test Kit Determines Immunity Against COVID-19 and Its Variants
Channels
Clinical Chemistry
view channelAI and Nanotechnology Enable Five-Minute Urine Drug Screening
Rapid screening for illicit drugs remains challenging when testing must be performed at the point of care. Laboratory methods provide accurate results but require sample preparation and specialized equipment,... Read more
Study Questions Uniform Stool-Test Cutoff Across Age Groups
Colorectal cancer remains a major clinical challenge, ranking as the fourth most common cancer and the second-leading cause of cancer death in the U.K. Early-onset colorectal cancer, defined as diagnosis... Read moreMolecular Diagnostics
view channel
Blood RNA Patterns Linked to CAR T-Cell Response and Survival in Lymphoma
Anti-CD19 chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy, which involves engineering a patient’s own immune cells to recognize and attack cancer cells, has transformed treatment for large B-cell lymphoma,... Read moreGenome Sequencing Provides Clues to Unexplained Recurrent Miscarriages
Recurrent pregnancy loss, defined as two or more miscarriages, affects about 5% of couples. In many cases, routine evaluation does not identify a cause, particularly when pregnancies have a normal chromosome... Read moreHematology
view channel
Werfen Gains FDA Clearance for ROTEM sigma Cartridge Use in Trauma
Traumatic injuries account for approximately 10% of deaths worldwide, with uncontrolled bleeding remaining a leading cause of potentially preventable trauma-related death. Trauma-induced coagulopathy further... Read more
Serial Blood Samples Reveal Leukemia’s Evolution Decades Before Diagnosis
Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is an aggressive blood cancer affecting approximately 2,700 people in the U.K. annually, with only about one in six patients surviving five years after diagnosis.... Read moreImmunology
view channel
Survey Finds Gap Between Food Allergy Testing Awareness and Clinical Practice
Food allergy evaluation can be challenging when laboratory results do not match clinical symptoms. Broad food allergy panels may detect sensitization without confirming an actual allergy, potentially leading... Read more
Multiplex PCR Test Gains CE Marking to Support Respiratory Infection Diagnosis
Acute respiratory infections often present with overlapping symptoms, making it difficult to distinguish between viral and bacterial causes. Seasonal surges of influenza-like illness in Europe further... Read more
Antibody Testing Informs Melioidosis Diagnosis and Surveillance in Emerging Regions
Melioidosis is a serious and sometimes fatal infection caused by the soil- and water-dwelling bacterium Burkholderia pseudomallei. People and animals can contract the disease through exposure to contaminated... Read moreMicrobiology
view channel
WHO Survey Reveals Gaps in Antimicrobial Resistance Testing and Response
Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) remains a major challenge for health systems, limiting effective treatment options for drug-resistant infections. These infections caused more than 1 million deaths and contributed... Read more
Direct-From-Specimen Pneumonia Test Detects Pathogens and Resistance in Hours
Pneumonia is a leading cause of sepsis and is associated with high mortality. Conventional culture-based pathogen identification and antimicrobial susceptibility testing can take two to four days, delaying... Read morePathology
view channel
Researchers Evaluate Automated Tissue Analysis Across Four Cancer Types
Histopathology image analysis plays a central role in cancer diagnosis, but tumor tissue can vary considerably across different regions of the same specimen. Pathologists examine cellular morphology, nuclear... Read more
AI Prostate Cancer Test Added to NCCN Guidelines for Post-Surgery Recurrence
Following radical prostatectomy, an estimated 20% to 40% of prostate cancer patients develop biochemical recurrence, marked by rising prostate-specific antigen levels that may indicate cancer recurrence.... Read more
New Training Approach Helps AI Distinguish Neighboring Cells in Tissue
Artificial intelligence (AI) can assist with identifying cells in digital pathology images, but densely packed tissue remains difficult to analyze. Neighboring cells may be merged, counted twice, or missed,... Read more
Review Highlights Progress and Validation Needs for AI in Digital Pathology
Pathology remains the gold standard for disease diagnosis, but clinical laboratories face growing demands for faster, more reproducible diagnostic and prognostic workflows. Digital pathology based on whole-slide... Read moreTechnology
view channel
Experimental Blood Test Detects Markers of Three Cancers and Alzheimer’s Disease
Colorectal cancer, glioblastoma, pancreatic cancer, and Alzheimer’s disease are serious conditions in which earlier detection may improve clinical outcomes. Blood-based testing could help identify dis... Read more
New qPCR Master Mixes Offer Broad Compatibility for Routine Research
Quantitative PCR (qPCR) workflows require consistent reagent performance across instruments and assay formats. Laboratories must also manage costs without changing established protocols.... Read moreIndustry
view channel
Labcorp Partners With Grupo Fleury to Expand Clinical Trial Operations in Brazil
Multinational clinical trials require laboratory partners that combine global expertise with local operational capabilities. Brazil is an important clinical research destination, supported by its diverse... Read more








