Immunological Tests Are Superior for Colon Cancer Screening
|
By LabMedica International staff writers Posted on 18 Jul 2013 |
|
Image: OC-Sensor fully automated fecal occult blood analyzer (Photo courtesy of Eiken Chemical).
The fecal immunochemical tests (FITs) for hemoglobin offer a number of advantages over traditional guaiac based fecal occult blood tests (gFOBTs).
The major advantage seems to come at the price of higher positivity rates and lower specificity and hence a higher load of work-up colonoscopies, which makes a final judgment of the superiority of either test difficult.
Scientists from the German Cancer Research Center (Heidelberg, Germany) compared three quantitative FITs with a gFOBT among participants of the German screening colonoscopy program. They obtained stool samples and colonoscopy reports from 2,235 participants of screening colonoscopy from 2005 to 2009. Patients willing to participate were given stool collection instructions and devices, including a small container and one test card for a gFOBT (HemOccult, Beckman Coulter; Krefeld, Germany).
The stored stool samples were assayed with two automated, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) based FITs, RIDASCREEN Haemoglobin, and RIDASCREEN Haemo-/Haptoglobin Complex, (R-Biopharm AG; Darmstadt, Germany). Cut-offs for positivity was 2 μg hemoglobin per gram stool. The stool samples were further analyzed, including a third FIT, OC-SENSOR, (Eiken Chemical; Tokyo, Japan).
The enzyme-based test detected one third of all colon cancer cases, about 9% of advanced precancerous adenomas lesions, and about 5% of early precancerous lesions. In 95 out of 100 participants with negative test results, no tissue abnormalities were found in the subsequent colonoscopy. Despite the already high specificities of the gFOBT for all outcomes, ranging from 95.2% to 95.4%, specificities were even higher for each of the FITs and each outcome. With estimates between 96.8% and 97.8%, specificities with respect to the detection of any cancer or any advanced neoplasm were very high for all three FITs.
Hermann Brenner, MD, MPH, a professor of clinical epidemiology, and senior author of the study said, “For the first time we have shown by direct comparison that the diagnostic performance of immunological stool tests is significantly higher than that of the enzymatic test at the same rate of positive results. Tests for occult blood in the stool will continue to be an important part of colon cancer screening. We therefore recommend including immunological tests in cancer screening programs in Germany. Many more people would thus benefit by obtaining a life-saving clue pointing to a hidden case of cancer.” The study was published on May 22, 2013, in the European Journal of Cancer.
Related Links:
Beckman Coulter
R-Biopharm
Eiken Chemical
The major advantage seems to come at the price of higher positivity rates and lower specificity and hence a higher load of work-up colonoscopies, which makes a final judgment of the superiority of either test difficult.
Scientists from the German Cancer Research Center (Heidelberg, Germany) compared three quantitative FITs with a gFOBT among participants of the German screening colonoscopy program. They obtained stool samples and colonoscopy reports from 2,235 participants of screening colonoscopy from 2005 to 2009. Patients willing to participate were given stool collection instructions and devices, including a small container and one test card for a gFOBT (HemOccult, Beckman Coulter; Krefeld, Germany).
The stored stool samples were assayed with two automated, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) based FITs, RIDASCREEN Haemoglobin, and RIDASCREEN Haemo-/Haptoglobin Complex, (R-Biopharm AG; Darmstadt, Germany). Cut-offs for positivity was 2 μg hemoglobin per gram stool. The stool samples were further analyzed, including a third FIT, OC-SENSOR, (Eiken Chemical; Tokyo, Japan).
The enzyme-based test detected one third of all colon cancer cases, about 9% of advanced precancerous adenomas lesions, and about 5% of early precancerous lesions. In 95 out of 100 participants with negative test results, no tissue abnormalities were found in the subsequent colonoscopy. Despite the already high specificities of the gFOBT for all outcomes, ranging from 95.2% to 95.4%, specificities were even higher for each of the FITs and each outcome. With estimates between 96.8% and 97.8%, specificities with respect to the detection of any cancer or any advanced neoplasm were very high for all three FITs.
Hermann Brenner, MD, MPH, a professor of clinical epidemiology, and senior author of the study said, “For the first time we have shown by direct comparison that the diagnostic performance of immunological stool tests is significantly higher than that of the enzymatic test at the same rate of positive results. Tests for occult blood in the stool will continue to be an important part of colon cancer screening. We therefore recommend including immunological tests in cancer screening programs in Germany. Many more people would thus benefit by obtaining a life-saving clue pointing to a hidden case of cancer.” The study was published on May 22, 2013, in the European Journal of Cancer.
Related Links:
Beckman Coulter
R-Biopharm
Eiken Chemical
Gold Member
Immunochromatographic Assay
CRYPTO Cassette
Automated MALDI-TOF MS System
EXS 3000
Capillary Blood Collection Tube
IMPROMINI M3
Latest Immunology News
- Ultrasensitive Liquid Biopsy Demonstrates Efficacy in Predicting Immunotherapy Response
- Blood Test Could Identify Colon Cancer Patients to Benefit from NSAIDs
- Blood Test Could Detect Adverse Immunotherapy Effects
- Routine Blood Test Can Predict Who Benefits Most from CAR T-Cell Therapy
- New Test Distinguishes Vaccine-Induced False Positives from Active HIV Infection
- Gene Signature Test Predicts Response to Key Breast Cancer Treatment
- Chip Captures Cancer Cells from Blood to Help Select Right Breast Cancer Treatment
- Blood-Based Liquid Biopsy Model Analyzes Immunotherapy Effectiveness
- Signature Genes Predict T-Cell Expansion in Cancer Immunotherapy
- Molecular Microscope Diagnostic System Assesses Lung Transplant Rejection
- Blood Test Tracks Treatment Resistance in High-Grade Serous Ovarian Cancer
- Luminescent Probe Measures Immune Cell Activity in Real Time
- Blood-Based Immune Cell Signatures Could Guide Treatment Decisions for Critically Ill Patients
- Novel Tool Predicts Most Effective Multiple Sclerosis Medication for Patients
- Companion Diagnostic Test for CRC Patients Identifies Eligible Treatment Population
- Novel Tool Uses Deep Learning for Precision Cancer Therapy
Channels
Clinical Chemistry
view channel
Compact Raman Imaging System Detects Subtle Tumor Signals
Accurate cancer diagnosis often depends on labor-intensive tissue staining and expert pathological review, which can delay results and limit access to rapid screening. These conventional methods also make... Read more
Noninvasive Blood-Glucose Monitoring to Replace Finger Pricks for Diabetics
People with diabetes often need to measure their blood glucose multiple times a day, most commonly through finger-prick blood tests or implanted sensors. These methods can be painful, inconvenient, and... Read more
Molecular Diagnostics
view channel
Blood Test Could Identify Biomarker Signature of Cerebral Malaria
Malaria remains a major cause of death and long-term disability in many low- and middle-income countries, with around 600,000 deaths reported globally each year. The most severe form, cerebral malaria,... Read more
World’s First Biomarker Blood Test to Assess MS Progression
Multiple sclerosis (MS) disease activity is caused by an abnormal immune response that results in damage to the brain and spinal cord. However, there is a lack of reliable tools to measure or predict MS progression.... Read more
Hematology
view channel
MRD Tests Could Predict Survival in Leukemia Patients
Acute myeloid leukemia is an aggressive blood cancer that disrupts normal blood cell production and often relapses even after intensive treatment. Clinicians currently lack early, reliable markers to predict... Read more
Platelet Activity Blood Test in Middle Age Could Identify Early Alzheimer’s Risk
Early detection of Alzheimer’s disease remains one of the biggest unmet needs in neurology, particularly because the biological changes underlying the disorder begin decades before memory symptoms appear.... Read more
Microvesicles Measurement Could Detect Vascular Injury in Sickle Cell Disease Patients
Assessing disease severity in sickle cell disease (SCD) remains challenging, especially when trying to predict hemolysis, vascular injury, and risk of complications such as vaso-occlusive crises.... Read more
ADLM’s New Coagulation Testing Guidance to Improve Care for Patients on Blood Thinners
Direct oral anticoagulants (DOACs) are one of the most common types of blood thinners. Patients take them to prevent a host of complications that could arise from blood clotting, including stroke, deep... Read moreMicrobiology
view channel
New UTI Diagnosis Method Delivers Antibiotic Resistance Results 24 Hours Earlier
Urinary tract infections affect around 152 million people every year, making them one of the most common bacterial infections worldwide. In routine medical practice, diagnosis often relies on rapid urine... Read more
Breakthroughs in Microbial Analysis to Enhance Disease Prediction
Microorganisms shape human health, ecosystems, and the planet’s climate, yet identifying them and understanding how they are related remains a major scientific challenge. Even with modern DNA sequencing,... Read more
Pathology
view channel
Genetics and AI Improve Diagnosis of Aortic Stenosis
Aortic stenosis is a progressive narrowing of the aortic valve that restricts blood flow from the heart and can be fatal if left untreated. There are currently no medical therapies that can prevent or... Read more
AI Tool Simultaneously Identifies Genetic Mutations and Disease Type
Interpreting genetic test results remains a major challenge in modern medicine, particularly for rare and complex diseases. While existing tools can indicate whether a genetic mutation is harmful, they... Read more
Rapid Low-Cost Tests Can Prevent Child Deaths from Contaminated Medicinal Syrups
Medicinal syrups contaminated with toxic chemicals have caused the deaths of hundreds of children worldwide, exposing a critical gap in how these products are tested before reaching patients.... Read more
Tumor Signals in Saliva and Blood Enable Non-Invasive Monitoring of Head and Neck Cancer
Head and neck cancers are among the most aggressive malignancies worldwide, with nearly 900,000 new cases diagnosed each year. Monitoring these cancers for recurrence or relapse typically relies on tissue... Read moreTechnology
view channel
AI Predicts Colorectal Cancer Survival Using Clinical and Molecular Features
Colorectal cancer is one of the most common and deadly cancers worldwide, and accurately predicting patient survival remains a major clinical challenge. Traditional prognostic tools often rely on either... Read more
Diagnostic Chip Monitors Chemotherapy Effectiveness for Brain Cancer
Glioblastoma is one of the most aggressive and fatal brain cancers, with most patients surviving less than two years after diagnosis. Treatment is particularly challenging because the tumor infiltrates... Read more
Industry
view channel
BD and Penn Institute Collaborate to Advance Immunotherapy through Flow Cytometry
BD (Becton, Dickinson and Company, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) has entered into a strategic collaboration with the Institute for Immunology and Immune Health (I3H, Philadelphia, PA, USA) at the University... Read more
