Prostate Cancer Screening Improved by Repeating Abnormal Tests
|
By LabMedica International staff writers Posted on 29 Dec 2015 |

Image: Micrograph from a prostate biopsy showing a prostatic adenocarcinoma, conventional (acinar) type, the most common form of prostate cancer (Photo courtesy of Nephron).
For more than 20 years, the prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test has been used to help screen for prostate cancer, but in recent years, some task forces have called for this blood test to be abandoned because it leads to many unnecessary biopsies.
Prostate-specific antigen may be elevated because of prostate cancer or as a result of infection, physical activity, or sexual activity. Variation in PSA concentrations can also be due to normal biological fluctuation or analytic and laboratory assay differences. As a result, PSA is sensitive but not specific for detecting prostate cancer, especially when levels are moderately elevated between 4 and 10 ng/mL.
Physicians and scientists at The Ottawa Hospital (ON, Canada) reviewed the medical records of 1,268 men who had an abnormal (high) PSA test result and were evaluated at the Ottawa Regional Cancer Assessment Centre between 2008 and 2013. In 25% of these men, the second PSA test came back normal. Only 28% of men with conflicting test results underwent a biopsy compared to 62% of men who had two abnormal test results, representing a 55% reduction in biopsies. In addition, only 3% of men with conflicting test results who had a biopsy were diagnosed with cancer within the year, compared to 19% of men who had two abnormal tests, suggesting that the second normal test is important. Repeated PSA test results were normal in 315 patients (24.8%).
Rodney H. Breau, MSc, MD, the senior author of the study said, “It is clear to me that any man with an abnormal PSA test should have this test repeated before a decision to biopsy. Some doctors and patients may be worried about missing a significant cancer diagnosis if they forgo a biopsy after conflicting test results, but our study shows this is very unlikely. It is also important to remember that the PSA test is just one factor we evaluate when deciding to do a biopsy, and these decisions are always made together with the patient, and can be revisited if risk factors change.” According to the Canadian Cancer Society, approximately 24,000 Canadians will be diagnosed with prostate cancer each year and the five-year survival rate is 96%. A PSA test costs approximately CAD 30, while a prostate biopsy costs approximately CAD 880.
The study was published on December 10, 2105, in the journal Mayo Clinic Proceedings.
Related Links:
The Ottawa Hospital
Prostate-specific antigen may be elevated because of prostate cancer or as a result of infection, physical activity, or sexual activity. Variation in PSA concentrations can also be due to normal biological fluctuation or analytic and laboratory assay differences. As a result, PSA is sensitive but not specific for detecting prostate cancer, especially when levels are moderately elevated between 4 and 10 ng/mL.
Physicians and scientists at The Ottawa Hospital (ON, Canada) reviewed the medical records of 1,268 men who had an abnormal (high) PSA test result and were evaluated at the Ottawa Regional Cancer Assessment Centre between 2008 and 2013. In 25% of these men, the second PSA test came back normal. Only 28% of men with conflicting test results underwent a biopsy compared to 62% of men who had two abnormal test results, representing a 55% reduction in biopsies. In addition, only 3% of men with conflicting test results who had a biopsy were diagnosed with cancer within the year, compared to 19% of men who had two abnormal tests, suggesting that the second normal test is important. Repeated PSA test results were normal in 315 patients (24.8%).
Rodney H. Breau, MSc, MD, the senior author of the study said, “It is clear to me that any man with an abnormal PSA test should have this test repeated before a decision to biopsy. Some doctors and patients may be worried about missing a significant cancer diagnosis if they forgo a biopsy after conflicting test results, but our study shows this is very unlikely. It is also important to remember that the PSA test is just one factor we evaluate when deciding to do a biopsy, and these decisions are always made together with the patient, and can be revisited if risk factors change.” According to the Canadian Cancer Society, approximately 24,000 Canadians will be diagnosed with prostate cancer each year and the five-year survival rate is 96%. A PSA test costs approximately CAD 30, while a prostate biopsy costs approximately CAD 880.
The study was published on December 10, 2105, in the journal Mayo Clinic Proceedings.
Related Links:
The Ottawa Hospital
Latest Clinical Chem. News
- Skin Swab Research Identifies Metabolic Changes Linked to Parkinson’s Disease
- AI Predicts Kidney Stone Composition From Routine Urine Tests
- Updated PSA Testing Guidelines Support Early Prostate Cancer Detection
- Antibody-Free Blood Test Detects Rheumatic Heart Disease Biomarker
- Blood and Spinal Fluid Biomarker May Help Track Early Huntington’s Disease
- New Biomarker Offers Longer Detection Window for Suspected GHB Exposure
- Study Finds Urine Biomarker Score Improves Five-Year Cancer Risk Prediction
- Flow Cytometry Tests Receive FDA Clearance for B-Cell Lymphoma Diagnosis
- Blood Protein Signatures May Predict Brain Vessel Damage and Cognitive Decline
- Combined Blood and Imaging Data Help Identify More Lung Cancer Cases
- Blood Protein Panel Detects ALS with High Accuracy
- Single-Vesicle Analysis Reveals Tissue-Associated Inflammatory Signatures
- Plasma Proteomic Test Detects Immunotherapy Resistance Before Imaging in Lung Cancer
- Blood Protein Analysis Reveals Menopause-Associated Signals of Brain Aging
- Noninvasive Tests Offer Alternatives to Biopsy for Assessing Advanced Liver Scarring
- Blood-Based Score May Support Targeted Interventions for Healthier Aging
Channels
Molecular Diagnostics
view channel
Epigenetic Blood Test Detects Early Breast Cancer and Predicts Recurrence Risk
Breast cancer screening can reduce mortality, but early detection remains challenging when tumors are small or difficult to identify through imaging. Blood-based liquid biopsies offer a potential complementary... Read more
Target-Amplification-Free CRISPR Platform Demonstrates Molecular Detection in Under 10 Minutes
Molecular testing plays an important role in clinical diagnostics, but conventional workflows often require time-consuming procedures and specialized equipment, limiting their use outside centralized laboratories.... Read more
Fapon Showcases AI-Engineered Enzymes and RNA Workflows at AMP 2026
Fapon showcased its AI-engineered enzymes, reverse transcription technologies, and nucleic acid library preparation solutions at the Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) 2026 Annual Meeting &... Read moreAMP 2026 Underscores Molecular Testing’s Role in Precision Medicine for Women’s Health
Advances in molecular diagnostics are creating new opportunities to improve the detection of sexually transmitted infections, identify antibiotic resistance, and assess cancer recurrence risk in women.... Read moreHematology
view channel
Serial Blood Samples Reveal Leukemia’s Evolution Decades Before Diagnosis
Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is an aggressive blood cancer affecting approximately 2,700 people in the U.K. annually, with only about one in six patients surviving five years after diagnosis.... Read more
Study Confirms Blood Products Remain Viable After Three Weeks in the Arctic
Trauma and hemorrhage care in Canada’s High Arctic is complicated by long evacuation times, extreme temperatures, and limited access to blood products. In remote military and northern communities, reaching... Read moreImmunology
view channel
Multiplex PCR Test Gains CE Marking to Support Respiratory Infection Diagnosis
Acute respiratory infections often present with overlapping symptoms, making it difficult to distinguish between viral and bacterial causes. Seasonal surges of influenza-like illness in Europe further... Read more
Antibody Testing Informs Melioidosis Diagnosis and Surveillance in Emerging Regions
Melioidosis is a serious and sometimes fatal infection caused by the soil- and water-dwelling bacterium Burkholderia pseudomallei. People and animals can contract the disease through exposure to contaminated... Read moreMicrobiology
view channel
Complete Malaria Genomes Could Improve Species Identification and Surveillance
Malaria remains a major global health challenge, with an estimated 282 million cases and 610,000 deaths worldwide in 2024. Although most research has focused on Plasmodium falciparum, Plasmodium ovale... Read more
Point-of-Care Test Detects Tuberculosis from Tongue Swab and Sputum
Tuberculosis remains a major infectious disease challenge, particularly in regions with limited access to diagnostic testing and treatment. Diagnosis can be time-consuming, and collecting sputum samples... Read more
Automated Microbial Identification and Susceptibility System Gains FDA Clearance
Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a leading global public health threat, causing an estimated 1.27 million deaths annually. The growing challenge of diagnosing and treating resistant infections highlights... Read more
Gastrointestinal Flex Assay Gains EU Certification for Tailored Pathogen Testing
Gastrointestinal infections can be caused by bacterial, viral, or parasitic pathogens, making targeted test selection important for clinical laboratories. Fixed syndromic panels may be broader than necessary... Read morePathology
view channel
AI Prostate Cancer Test Added to NCCN Guidelines for Post-Surgery Recurrence
Following radical prostatectomy, an estimated 20% to 40% of prostate cancer patients develop biochemical recurrence, marked by rising prostate-specific antigen levels that may indicate cancer recurrence.... Read more
New Training Approach Helps AI Distinguish Neighboring Cells in Tissue
Artificial intelligence (AI) can assist with identifying cells in digital pathology images, but densely packed tissue remains difficult to analyze. Neighboring cells may be merged, counted twice, or missed,... Read more
Review Highlights Progress and Validation Needs for AI in Digital Pathology
Pathology remains the gold standard for disease diagnosis, but clinical laboratories face growing demands for faster, more reproducible diagnostic and prognostic workflows. Digital pathology based on whole-slide... Read moreTechnology
view channel
New qPCR Master Mixes Offer Broad Compatibility for Routine Research
Quantitative PCR (qPCR) workflows require consistent reagent performance across instruments and assay formats. Laboratories must also manage costs without changing established protocols.... Read more
Multi-Agent AI Framework Supports Laboratory Quality and Workflow Monitoring
Clinical laboratories analyze blood, urine, tissue, and other bodily fluids to support disease diagnosis and treatment. Rising test volumes, workforce shortages, and increasingly complex diagnostics are... Read moreIndustry
view channel
Natera and Incyte Collaborate on MRD-Guided Colorectal Cancer Treatment Study
Natera (Austin, TX, USA) has entered into a clinical collaboration with Incyte (Wilmington, DE, USA) for a Phase II study evaluating molecular residual disease (MRD)-guided treatment in colorectal cancer.... Read more
Partnership Aims to Bring Blood-Based Alzheimer’s Testing to Japan
Alzheimer’s disease remains a growing diagnostic challenge as populations age and cognitive impairment becomes more common. In Japan, government-supported estimates project that approximately 4.... Read more







