Combining Two Diagnostic Tests Drastically Reduces Cancer Miss Rates
|
By LabMedica International staff writers Posted on 17 May 2016 |
|
Image: A photomicrograph of an abnormal Pap smear showing changes consistent with Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) and Mild Dysplasia. Note the irregular perinuclear cytoplasmic clearing, which is the key characteristic of identifying HPV visually on a Pap smear (Photo courtesy of Dr. Cynthia D Booth, MD).
The Papanicolaou (Pap) test is recommended for women between 21 and 65 years old as a screening test for cervical cancer. Women 30 and older who are negative on co-testing may wait as long as five years for their next testing, but physicians still recommend annual examinations.
In recent years, high-risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) testing for triaging atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance and co-testing with cytology have been implemented in clinical practice. However, clinical data for primary screening with human papillomavirus (HPV) testing alone are currently lacking.
Scientists at the Houston Methodist Hospital (Houston, TX, USA) and their colleagues retrospectively reviewed the correlation of cytology, histology, and hrHPV testing through the use of a cytology laboratory quality assurance database with 130,648 Papanicolaou (Pap) tests interpreted at the BioReference Laboratories (Houston, TX, USA) and Houston Methodist Hospital between March 1, 2013, and June 30, 2014. Among the 47,499 patients who had undergone cytology-HPV co-testing, 1,654 underwent follow-up biopsies.
The sensitivities of the hrHPV and Pap tests were 80.8% and 81.2%, respectively, for detecting any type of cervicovaginal dysplasia and 91.3% and 90.9%, respectively, for high-grade cervicovaginal lesions. For the 253 biopsy-confirmed high-grade cervicovaginal lesions (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2+, adenocarcinoma in situ, or carcinoma), the false-negative rates for hrHPV and Pap tests were 8.7% and 9.1%, respectively. When they combined the tests, the teams found only three of the 253 cases were double negatives for both the Pap and hrHPV test. Therefore the false-negative rate for cytology-hrHPV co-testing was only 1.2%.
Dina Mody, MD, director of cytopathology at Houston Methodist Hospital and co-author of the study said, “We have known that neither test is perfect and misses a certain number of cases, but we did not realize until we analyzed the data just how impactful the combination of these tests would be. The numbers tell me that Obstetrics and Gynecology specialists need to regularly offer co-testing, and woman age 30 or older need to proactively request co-testing.” The study was published in the May 2016 issue of the journal Cancer Cytopathology.
Related Links:
Houston Methodist Hospital
BioReference Laboratories
In recent years, high-risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) testing for triaging atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance and co-testing with cytology have been implemented in clinical practice. However, clinical data for primary screening with human papillomavirus (HPV) testing alone are currently lacking.
Scientists at the Houston Methodist Hospital (Houston, TX, USA) and their colleagues retrospectively reviewed the correlation of cytology, histology, and hrHPV testing through the use of a cytology laboratory quality assurance database with 130,648 Papanicolaou (Pap) tests interpreted at the BioReference Laboratories (Houston, TX, USA) and Houston Methodist Hospital between March 1, 2013, and June 30, 2014. Among the 47,499 patients who had undergone cytology-HPV co-testing, 1,654 underwent follow-up biopsies.
The sensitivities of the hrHPV and Pap tests were 80.8% and 81.2%, respectively, for detecting any type of cervicovaginal dysplasia and 91.3% and 90.9%, respectively, for high-grade cervicovaginal lesions. For the 253 biopsy-confirmed high-grade cervicovaginal lesions (cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2+, adenocarcinoma in situ, or carcinoma), the false-negative rates for hrHPV and Pap tests were 8.7% and 9.1%, respectively. When they combined the tests, the teams found only three of the 253 cases were double negatives for both the Pap and hrHPV test. Therefore the false-negative rate for cytology-hrHPV co-testing was only 1.2%.
Dina Mody, MD, director of cytopathology at Houston Methodist Hospital and co-author of the study said, “We have known that neither test is perfect and misses a certain number of cases, but we did not realize until we analyzed the data just how impactful the combination of these tests would be. The numbers tell me that Obstetrics and Gynecology specialists need to regularly offer co-testing, and woman age 30 or older need to proactively request co-testing.” The study was published in the May 2016 issue of the journal Cancer Cytopathology.
Related Links:
Houston Methodist Hospital
BioReference Laboratories
Gold Member
Aspiration System
VACUSAFE
Manual Pipetting Aid
Pipette Controllers macro
Food Allergy Screening ELISA Kit
Allerquant 14G B ELISA
Latest Molecular Diagnostics News
- Blood Gene Expression Fluctuates More Than Expected Over Time
- Genomic Fingerprints Reveal Early Chemotherapy Resistance in Childhood Cancer
- Genomic Test Helps Early Breast Cancer Patients Avoid Chemotherapy
- Residual Disease Test Predicts Merkel Cell Carcinoma Recurrence Earlier Than Antibody Assay
- Portable Rapid Test Aims to Detect Ebola at Point of Care
- New Test Delivers Four Prenatal Genetic Screens from One Blood Sample
- Point-of-Care Molecular Technology Promises Transformative Shift in Oncology
- Multiplex PCR Test Differentiates Four Causes of Ulcerative Skin Lesions
- Blood Test Guides Patient Selection for Radiopharmaceutical Therapy in Prostate Cancer
- New Biomarker Helps Guide Combination Therapy for Treatment-Resistant Breast Cancer
- Blood-Based Gene Expression Test Detects Early Pancreatic Cancer
- Blood-Based Biomarker Panel Outperforms Existing Liver Disease Tests
- Fully Automated Test Advances Hepatitis D Diagnosis and Monitoring
- HPV Assay Gains Expanded CE Mark for Self-Collected Vaginal Samples
- Blood Test Achieves Improved Detection of Advanced Precancerous Colorectal Lesions
- Community-Based Genetic Screening Reaches Rural and Vulnerable Populations
Channels
Clinical Chemistry
view channel
Blood Protein Panel Predicts Timing of ALS Symptom Onset
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease in which clinical signs often emerge only after substantial motor neuron injury has already occurred, complicating timely intervention.... Read more
Siemens Adds CE-Marked Capillary Claims for 24 Assays on Atellica Analyzers
Venous blood draws can be challenging in patients with difficult veins, needle phobia, or limited blood volume, and they can slow collection in busy services. Core laboratories also face pressure to expand... Read more
Molecular Diagnostics
view channel
Genomic Fingerprints Reveal Early Chemotherapy Resistance in Childhood Cancer
Chemotherapy remains central to treating childhood cancers, yet its toxic effects can injure healthy tissues, and some tumors later relapse or spread. Clinicians have lacked early molecular markers that... Read more
Blood Gene Expression Fluctuates More Than Expected Over Time
Blood-based gene expression is widely used to explore disease biology, but temporal variability can complicate interpretation of single time-point measurements. Seasonal shifts, time of day, and subclinical... Read more
Genomic Test Helps Early Breast Cancer Patients Avoid Chemotherapy
Adjuvant chemotherapy decisions in early breast cancer can expose many patients to toxicities without clear benefit when clinical factors alone do not precisely predict recurrence risk. Clinicians therefore... Read more
Residual Disease Test Predicts Merkel Cell Carcinoma Recurrence Earlier Than Antibody Assay
Merkel cell carcinoma is a rare, aggressive skin cancer with a substantial risk of relapse, occurring in about 40% of patients. Surveillance remains challenging because widely used serologic monitoring... Read moreHematology
view channel
Spectral Flow Cytometry Assay Enhances MRD Detection in Multiple Myeloma
imal residual disease (MRD) monitoring is pivotal in multiple myeloma, where persistent malignant plasma cells drive relapse risk and help guide therapy decisions. In the United States, approximately 202,000... Read more
New Marker Helps Detect Aggressive Multiple Myeloma Earlier
Multiple myeloma is an incurable malignancy of plasma cells and the second most common blood cancer worldwide, with more than 188,000 new cases each year. Although therapies have advanced, most patients... Read more
Immunology
view channel
Study Reveals Immune Mechanism Driving Severe COVID-19 Progression
Severe COVID-19 has highlighted gaps in understanding of early antiviral responses, particularly why some patients deteriorate despite timely care. Type I interferons are central to host defense, yet their... Read more
Antibody Profiling Identifies Preclinical Inflammatory Bowel Disease Years Before Diagnosis
Inflammatory bowel disease often develops after a prolonged symptom-free period, complicating timely recognition and clinical intervention. Limited understanding of immune activity during this silent phase... Read more
Ultrasensitive Blood Test Detects Sjögren’s Signature Years Before Diagnosis
Sjögren’s disease is a common autoimmune condition that can be difficult to recognize early, leading to delayed diagnosis and persistent symptom burden. It affects around half a million people in the UK... Read more
New Assays Expand Cytokine Testing for Transplant and Immunocompromised Patients
Eurofins Viracor has introduced three plasma-based assays—CXCL9 (Test Code 33607), CXCL10 (Test Code 33609), and interleukin-18 (IL-18) (Test Code 33611)—expanding its immunology testing menu for transplant... Read moreMicrobiology
view channel
High-Throughput Automated Platform to Advance Latent Tuberculosis Testing
Testing for tuberculosis remains a persistent global need, with demand driven by immigration screening, pre-treatment evaluation for immunosuppressive therapies, and public health programs.... Read more
Expanded Diagnostics and Therapies Target Rising Gonorrhea Resistance
Drug-resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae is straining current treatment protocols and elevating the risk of complications across sexual health services. More than 500,000 cases are reported each year in the... Read more
Technology
view channel
Training Device Improves Accuracy of Pooled Molecular Diagnostics
High-throughput molecular diagnostics have transformed infectious disease detection, but many workflows remain difficult to execute accurately without extensive training. Sample pooling can cut per‑test... Read more
New CE-Certified Software Advances Whole-Genome Cancer Testing
European hospitals are increasingly using comprehensive tumor genomics to guide therapy, but routine whole genome sequencing (WGS) requires validated, regulation-compliant workflows. A newly CE-certified... Read more
National Rare Disease Registry Standardizes Genetic and Clinical Data for Coordinated Care
Rare diseases collectively impose a significant clinical burden despite their individual rarity, often involving multisystem presentations and prolonged diagnostic journeys. Limited specialist expertise... Read more
Industry
view channel
LumiQuick Advances Oxidative Stress Research with Expanded AOXRE Portfolio
LumiQuick Diagnostics, Inc. (Santa Clara, CA, USA) has announced the addition of the AOXRE product line to its portfolio and introduced expanded services to help biotechnology and diagnostic companies... Read more
Collaboration Advances Sputum-Based Diagnostics for Asthma and COPD
Asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease are highly prevalent inflammatory airway conditions, affecting more than 40 million Americans and more than 650 million people worldwide.... Read more
